• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Pagley's Pasta & More: Delight in Authentic Italian Comfort Food

Pagley's Pasta & More, located in New Castle, PA, is a simple yet delightful Italian restaurant that offers a cozy and inviting atmosphere. Their menu boasts delicious dishes like chicken tenders, cheese ravioli, chicken Parmesan, and veal parm. The portions are generous, and the sauces are a standout feature, perfect for mopping up with their tasty bread. The friendly staff and efficient service ensure a pleasant dining experience. While the decor may be plain, the focus here is on the flavorful and satisfying food. Overall, Pagley's Pasta & More is a local favorite for delicious Italian fare.

Pagley's Pasta & More at a glance

  • Address 1235 E Washington St New Castle, PA 16101
  • Phone (724) 658-3066
  • Restaurant type Italian restaurant , Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Pagley's Pasta & More: Reviews & Ratings

Joseph Caporale
4

I've eaten here way before the pandemic. Had the veal parmesan it was very good. Just recently had the pizza, Unique sauce, Flaky crust, Wife and her friends from church went there and they all enjoyed it

Joe Funkhouser
5

This place is amazing you couldn't ask for a better Italian restaurant. My 8-year-old absolutely loves the calamari. She gets it anytime and every time we go there. This is one of my mom and pop's favorite places to go to eat after church. The staff are always amazing

Will Koz
5

Pagley’s Pasta & More is a New Castle classic! My family and I have been coming here for years, it’s a true staple of the Italian Sunday dinner scene here in New Castle. The pink sauce? Absolutely top-tier. Creamy, flavorful, and the best around. Whether it’s pasta, chicken parm, or anything in between, you can’t go wrong. Feels like home every time!

Jay
5

in love with the ravioli and chicken pastene but didn’t get pictures of both come here every other week staff is nothing but friendly and amazing! All the girls make you feel at home! I’d definitely try it if you haven’t

Norm Goings
5

The food was absolutely amazing. Everything we had was superb and priced very competitively. The service was fine but pretty slow, it wasn't our server's fault, she was great but there only seemed to be two servers in the whole place during Saturday dinner service. The atmosphere... you don't go here for the ambience you go for the food. We will definitely be back.

Daniel Zappola
5

Everything I’ve had there has been excellent, but I think the cheese raviolis are my favorite. They are over stuffed and so good. I hope one day they start selling them frozen so I can take them home and put my own sauce on them that would be excellent. Although I really do like their sauce also.

Emily Hawkins
5

Excellent food and atmosphere! Quick & friendly service!

Izabella Browning
5

Food was delicious! Atmosphere was very empty and dated. Only $60 for three people with multiple plates of food! Amazingly huge and delicious portions! Waitress name was Taylor! Excellent as well! Definitely recommend

Location

  • Pagley's Pasta & More
    Pagley's Pasta & More
    1235 E Washington St New Castle, PA 16101 Hotline: (724) 658-3066

Located in the heart of New Castle, Pennsylvania, Pagley's Pasta & More is a delightful Italian restaurant that offers a range of delectable dishes for the whole family to enjoy. This charming establishment ticks all the boxes when it comes to dining preferences - from casual dress to outdoor seating, and even delivery and takeout options.

One standout feature of Pagley's Pasta & More is its welcoming and efficient staff, as highlighted by customer reviews. The owner, Tony, and the person at the register, Anthony Hooker, ensure that each guest feels right at home from the moment they walk in.

When it comes to the food at Pagley's, customers rave about the generous portions and delicious flavors. From crispy chicken tenders to giant cheese raviolis and mouth-watering chicken Parmesan, there is something for everyone on the menu. The 12-cut pizza with meatballs is a definite crowd-pleaser, and many patrons have even taken home their signature sauce to enjoy later.

While some reviewers mention that the ambiance of Pagley's Pasta & More may not be the fanciest, the focus here is on simple, wholesome Italian cuisine that hits the spot every time. Whether you're a local looking for a go-to spot or a visitor in search of an authentic Italian meal, Pagley's Pasta & More delivers on all fronts. So, if you find yourself craving a hearty Italian feast in New Castle, look no further than Pagley's Pasta & More.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards